The fate of the Waikiki Natatorium War Memorial—the aging salt-water public swimming pool and standing war monument—grows more dubious by the day.

Last week, a task force appointed by Honolulu Mayor Mufi Hannemann voted 9-3 to demolish the natatorium’s dilapidated pool and façade, and relocate the memorial’s iconic Beaux Arts-style entrance arch to nearby Kapiolani Park.

What will take the 82-year-old natatorium’s place? More Waikiki beach, and lots of it. The task force proposed building two groins to extend adjacent Kaimana Beach roughly 100 meters.

According to the task force, demolishing the natatorium and expanding the beach will cost $15.1 million. But fully restoring the natatorium would cost $57 million.

Built to honor 101 Hawaii soldiers who died in World War I, the natatorium opened to great fanfare on August 24, 1927. Legendary Hawaii surfer Duke Kahanamoku swam the saltwater pool’s inaugural lap in front of a capacity crowd. Notable athletes like Olympians Buster Crabbe and Johnny Weismuller also swam in the natatorium pool.

Years of neglect led the natatorium to fall into disrepair, and the state shuttered the facility in 1979 for safety concerns. It has been closed ever since. In 1995, the National Trust for Historic Preservation included the natatorium on its list of the 11 most endangered historic sites in the U.S.

Mayor Hannemann will decide what’s next for the landmark. Not a good sign for memorial supporters: Hannemann has been vocal about razing the natatorium in the past.

There’s “no definitive date “ to when Hannemann will make his decision, says city spokesman Bill Brennan. “The mayor would like to put in some plan of action sooner than later.”




Check out these related HawaiiMagazine.com posts:
Japanese Band Plays USS Missouri Memorial
Battleship Missouri celebrates a decade at Pearl Harbor
USS Arizona Memorial featured in largest war collection