best restaurants hawaii

Mama's Fish House. 
Photo: Keith Wills/Flickr

The best restaurant in Hawaii is…

You came. You ate. You voted. Here’s how travelers ranked the Islands' top restaurants in the 2017 Readers’ Choice Awards.

Hawaii’s food is among the top reasons to love this place. The Islands boast a richness of diversity in its cuisine that can only come from a place with such a melting pot of cultures—part Asian, part European, part Hawaiian—and a wealth of fresh, local ingredients, including seafood, Island beef and tropical fruits and vegetables. It was a hotly contested category, but the results are in for Best Restaurant in Hawaii this year. Here’s how you ranked your favorite restaurants in the state.

1. Mama’s Fish House

 

A post shared by Melissa Kim (@misa.ki.whimsy) on

Paia, Maui • On the winner’s list year after year, this iconic fixture in Paia is the perfect mix of a stellar beachfront view, tropical getaway and luxury dining experience. From the gorgeous natural wood benches and eclectic, exotic kitsch décor, this restaurant does Hawaiian fusion food gloriously with appetizers served in a coconut, mouthwatering surf and turf entrees and creative tiki drinks – don’t forget the signature Black Pearl dessert. Thanks to the incredibly friendly service, it’s a long-time favorite for many travelers—the first place you call to make a reservation when touching down on the island. And, with its popularity, you’re definitely going to want to make a reservation.

799 Poho Pl., Paia, Maui. (808) 579-8488, mamasfishhouse.com.

 

2. Merriman’s

merrimans
Merriman's beef filet. 
Photo courtesy: Merriman's

Waimea, Hawaii Island • Celebrated chef Peter Merriman’s flagship restaurant, this community mainstay, with its fresh locally sourced ingredients and exquisite presentation has been serving up exciting Hawaii Regional Cuisine for 20 years. Crowd favorites include the perfectly cooked, freshly-caught fish and expertly customized beef filets. Don’t forget to order a sumptuous dessert, like the classic chocolate purse, and one of their legendary Mai Tais. Whether you visit for breakfast, brunch, lunch, happy hour or dinner, the consensus here is that Merriman’s is an experience you won’t soon forget.

65-1227B Opelo Rd., Kamuela, Waimea, Hawaii Island. (808) 885-6822, merrimanshawaii.com/waimea

 3. Kimo’s Maui 

 

A post shared by Yuzuho Kawatani (@yuzupon425) on

Lahaina, Maui • A community-conscious (they do a number of events annually for charity), beachfront dining establishment with a picture-perfect view of Lanai and Molokai known for its fresh local fish, succulent steaks and signature Hula Pie, Kimo’s has been a Maui favorite for just over 40 years. Guests love the koa-lined walls and vintage New England vibe of the upstairs lounge and the toes-in-the-sand downstairs area, where relaxing under an umbrella is the thing to do. Make reservations for sunset and stay after dinner for Hawaiian music and an excellent tropical Mai Tai.

845 Front Street, Suite A, Lahaina, Maui. (808) 661-4811, kimosmaui.com.

4. Alan Wong’s

 

GINGER CRUSTED ONAGA, LONG TAIL RED SNAPPER - Miso Sesame Vinaigrette, Mushroom and Corn.

A post shared by Alan Wong's Honolulu (@alanwongs) on

Honolulu, Oahu • Alan Wong’s is a name that comes up on every list of Hawaii’s best restaurants, and rightfully so. The James Beard-winning establishment, favorite of the Obama family and flagship culinary experiment of celebrity chef and Hawaii Regional Cuisine pioneer Alan Wong may not have an ocean view, but what’s important to its fans isn’t the location, it’s the exquisite, locally-sourced food. Fresh fish and seafood preparations are the stars of this show, from the Misokaki North Shore Tilapia to the shrimp and clam linguini, although the signature twice-cooked shortrib also gets top marks.

1857 S King St., Honolulu, Oahu. (808) 949-1939, alanwongs.com.

5. Haleiwa Joe’s

 

I think my dinner came from a dinosaur lol. 

A post shared by Alex (@soccermech8) on

Haleiwa, Oahu • With quality food in generous portions and a convenient location in historic Haleiwa Town, the original Haleiwa Joe’s, which boasts gorgeous views of the harbor, ocean and sunsets, is a versatile, much-loved semi-casual dining spot. A favorite of celebrities and the local surf crowd, it’s known for its monstrous prime rib (served in limited quantities, so get there early for it) and friendly, prompt service. Long after the sun goes down, this is the place to relax, listen to live music, and celebrate with friends on the weekend nights.

66-011 Kamehameha Hwy. Haleiwa, Oahu (808) 637-8005, haleiwajoes.com

You can find all of our winners in the March/April 2017 issue of HAWAIʻI Magazine, currently on newsstands nationwide or available as a single issue by calling our Circulation Department at 1-800-788-4230.