Photo: Courtesy of Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop

The 5 Best Bakeries on Maui

Our readers picked their favorite spots to get their sweet fix on Maui in our 2020 Readers’ Choice Awards.

Vote now in our 2021 Readers’ Choice Awards! Tell us which beaches, hiking trails, lūʻau, hotels, food trucks and surf spots are your favorites! The results will be printed in our March/April 2021 issue!

 

You’re on vacation. So, of course, dessert!

Maui has some of the best bakeries in the state, from old-school shops with loyal, third-generation customers to hip bakeries whipping up artisan goods using local ingredients. Here are the Top 5 bakeries picked by readers in our 2020 Readers’ Choice Awards. Bookmark these for your next trip to Maui.

1. Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop


While this restaurant may serve hoagies and hot dogs, Leoda’s is really a destination for pies. Freshly baked, scratch-made pies. Apple crumble, banana cream, chocolate-macadamia nut, coconut cream. It also serves savory and hand-held pies, too. Our recommendation: Eat on there—and order a couple more for the road. 820 Olowalu Village Road, Honoapiʻilani Highway, Lahaina, (808) 662-3600, leodas.com

2. T. Komoda Store & Bakery

Open since 1916, T. Komoda Store & Bakery is one of the oldest family-owned stores on the Valley Isle. While its cream puffs are what the bakery is most known for, you don’t want to miss the glazed doughnuts or malasadas, light and crispy and filled with guava, if you want. Go early because these do sell out. 3674 Baldwin Ave., Makawao, (808) 572-7261

3. Maui Pie


Owners Ryan and Kellee Houghtaling opened this bakery in a Kīhei strip mall with homey, homemade pies in flavors like apple, blueberry, lilikoʻi (passion fruit) and mango-strawberry. But you can find savory chicken pot pies, quiches and classic cream pies here, too. 1280 S. Kīhei Road, #101, Kīhei, (808) 298-0473, mauipie.com

4. Sugar Beach Bake Shop




View this post on Instagram


Sugar beach bake shop will open to the community tomorrow, 5/8/20! We will open daily between 6am-2pm, and here is what available tomorrow. To order, please call (6am-2pm) or email us. If you email us, please include when is the best time to call you, your order will not be confirmed without payment. You can drop in as well. Credit card transaction ONLY at this moment even with the in person purchase. Also please wear a mask and practice social distancing, and avoid visiting as a big group for everyone’s safety. Thank you for your understanding as we adopt these new changes. We are all new to this as well and will notify you of any updated procedures to serve you better daily. I would also just like to say, that we are so happy to be baking again! 🥰❤️

A post shared by Sugar Beach Bake Shop (@sugarbeachbakeshop) on

It’s carb heaven at this North Kīhei spot. Find mango cheesecake, cream-filled puffs, malasadas, scones, macadamia nut sticky buns and its signature lilikoʻi key lime pie. All of the pies are baked each morning and include fresh, locally sourced ingredients. 61 S. Kīhei Rd., Kīhei, (808) 757-8285, sugarbeachbakeshop.com

5. Home Maid Bakery


Since 1960, this bakery has been a Maui favorite, known for its crispy manju (Japanese sweet bean paste cookie), freshly made doughnuts, sweet breads, turnovers, pies and shortbread cookies. Must-trys are the chantilly cake, mochi (Japanese rice cakes) made-to-order malasadas and its famous carrot cake (order in advance). 1005 Lower Main Street, Wailuku, (808) 244-7015, homemaidbakery.com

Additional Information: 

For all the winners from our 2020 HAWAIʻI Magazine Readers’ Choice Awards, pick up a copy of our March/April 2020 issue by calling our Circulation Department at 800-788-4230, emailing help@hawaiimagazine.com or buying online now.